-
Ed Davey: Chocolate Teapot
Read More…: Ed Davey: Chocolate TeapotI lost patience with Ed Davey at around 2.30pm this afternoon. It was when Jason Beer read into the record the sheer number of red flags being waved in Ed Davey’s face about the Post Office’s behaviour and its dodgy Horizon IT system from the moment he took office. On 20 May 2010, the day Davey was appointed, Alan Bates wrote a letter on Justice For Subpostmasters Alliance headed paper. It read: “We are an independent group of ex and serving subpostmasters who have suffered at the hands of the Post Office and their Horizon system ever since it was…
-
Pat’s Proof Points (and other McFadden Mantras)
Read More…: Pat’s Proof Points (and other McFadden Mantras)Former Post Office minister (2007 – 2010) Pat McFadden didn’t have to say much to the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry, but he did have to say something. Being a campaign-hardened and experienced politician, he had no qualms about saying very little lots of times. McFadden was asked (in a number of ways) why he did nothing to help Subpostmasters, despite receiving clear information from his fellow MPs and detailed allegations from the journalist Rebecca Thomson, sent in the form of an email whilst she was putting together her seminal investigation for Computer Weekly, which broke this scandal in 2009.…
-
Comical Ken and Captain Kelly
Read More…: Comical Ken and Captain KellyKen McCall was brought into the Post Office in 2016 as a non-executive director (NED) because the Post Office chairman Tim Parker thought he would be a “good fit”. We were told this was because of McCall’s experience running a delivery business (TNT) in China and being responsible for EuropCar and its IT function in Europe, but it may well have been because he was a mediocre talent joining a mediocre board. McCall did no due diligence before joining the Post Office (for due diligence, read “basic Google search”) and was entirely unaware when he accepted the job that there…
-
Andy Dunks’ Big Problem
Read More…: Andy Dunks’ Big ProblemFujitsu’s Andy Dunks has a problem. He signed dozens, possibly hundreds of witness statements attesting to the integrity of the Horizon IT system without, it seems, taking the relevant amount of care to see if the information he put in his witness statements was true. These witness statements were used in the successful prosecutions of Subpostmasters. Today was about was probing to what extent Dunks knew (or should have known) the information he was presenting (or the way he was presenting it) was inadequate. Unlike his previous appearance before the Inquiry, Dunks was given a reminder of his privilege against…
-
Davey briefed to dismiss Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance Concerns in 2010
Read More…: Davey briefed to dismiss Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance Concerns in 2010The first meeting between Alan Bates from the Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance (JFSA) and a government minister took place on 5 October 2010. Ed Davey was, at the time, the Liberal Democrat minister responsible for the Post Office within the coalition government. The date was crucial: the trial of Seema Misra was less than a week away, and Channel 4 News were thinking of running something about the JFSA’s claims. Today the briefing note sent to Ed Davey by Mike Whitehead (a civil servant from the Shareholder Executive which monitored the Post Office Inquiry on behalf of the Business Department)…
-
Read stands aside to focus on Inquiry
Read More…: Read stands aside to focus on InquiryNick Read is stepping back from frontline duties as Post Office CEO to focus on Phase 7 of the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry. In an all-staff newsletter, sent today, Read wrote: “Following a discussion with Post Office Chair, Nigel Railton and the Board, we have agreed that I should give my entire attention to the task of preparing the business for Phase 7… It is vitally important that we demonstrate the changes we have made and give confidence to the Inquiry and the country at large that ‘nothing like this could happen again’.” Phase 7 of the Inquiry is…
-
Poor Tom
Read More…: Poor TomTom Cooper was pitched into the Post Office madness quite late in the scandal. He joined UK Government Investments in 2017, and became UKGI’s man on the Post Office board in March 2018 whilst it was already embroiled in litigation with with its Subpostmasters and careering towards the first of two disastrous High Court trials. Cooper is an accountant by trade, starting at KPMG before becoming an investment banker at UBS and Deutsche Bank. The handover with his predecessor Richard Callard (giving evidence on Friday) was not auspicious. Callard apparently reassured Cooper (per Second Sight’s interim report conclusions in 2013)…
-
Robert Swannell – Culture, Curiosity and Risk
Read More…: Robert Swannell – Culture, Curiosity and RiskRobert Swannell is a former accountant and barrister with more than thirty years experience as an investment banker and director of large companies (including six years as chair of Marks and Spencer). He is therefore a big deal. Big deals rarely feel they get things wrong. Swannell had two articles of faith – the first was that he massively improved the Shareholder Executive/UK Government Investments risk reporting whilst he was at the organisation (ShEx became UKGI) and the second was that ShEx/UKGI’s failure to spot the Post Office scandal until March 2019 was because up until that point the Post…
-
Down ShEx – UKGI on heat (maps) and relish
Read More…: Down ShEx – UKGI on heat (maps) and relishMark Russell has, in one form or another, been involved in the corporate governance of the Post Office from 2004 to today. He joined the government’s Shareholder Executive (ShEx) in 2004, became its CEO and then in 2014, when ShEx was absorbed into UK Government Investments (UKGI) he became CEO of that body until 2019 when he moved into a Senior Adviser and consultancy role. Russell was ultimately responsible for examining the business risks facing the government-owned Post Office, and by his own admission today, both he and his organisation completely missed the Horizon scandal until it was far too…
-
Post Office Chairman Tim Parker: Fatalistic Attraction
Read More…: Post Office Chairman Tim Parker: Fatalistic AttractionThe morning started on a light note. After Tim Parker had been sworn in, Jason Beer KC, who was asking questions on behalf of the Inquiry, took him to paragraph 268 of his 136 page witness statement. Beer told the Inquiry that Parker had written about the Post Office appointing “a criminal with extensive experience to work alongside Brian Altman QC”. Beer wondered if perhaps the word “silk” was missing?Parker agreed it was.So, suggested Beer, “rather than the Post Office appointing a criminal, the Post Office would appoint a criminal silk?”“Correct”, said Parker. Glad that was tidied up. Parker’s motivations…
Archives
- ▼2024
- ▼November (9)
- (19th) Post Office Inquiry costs to top £50m
- (12th) Chris Head: an open letter to Gareth Thomas, Post Office minister
- (11th) Lisa Busch KC
- (11th) Kemi Badenoch: I’m Great
- (9th) Make Good: the Post Office scandal musical
- (8th) Chisholm: helping Paula Vennells fail upwards
- (6th) Hollinrake’s legacy: Postmasters dying without full redress
- (5th) Recaldin: Post Office remediation is “Shot to Pieces”
- (4th) Simon Recaldin: The Process Gnome
- ▼November (9)
Most Popular
Tags
Alan Bates alice perkins Alwen Lyons Andrew Winn Andy Dunks Andy Parsons angela van den bogerd Bates v Post Office BBC Bonusgate CCRC Chris Aujard Clarke Advice False Accounts Fujitsu Gareth Jenkins Grabiner HCAB Horizon Hugh Flemington Inquiry Interim Report Janet Skinner Jarnail Singh Lee Castleton Lord Arbuthnot Mark Davies Nicki Arch Nick Read Noel Thomas Pam Stubbs Paula Vennells Paul Marshall Post Office Receipts and Payments mismatch bug Rob Wilson Rod Ismay Rodric Williams Second Sight Seema Misra ShEx Simon Clarke Susan Crichton Tracy Felstead UKGI
Categories
- Appeals (18)
- Blog (17)
- Book (10)
- Civil litigation (45)
- Compensation (37)
- Corporate (21)
- Fujitsu (29)
- Inquiry (115)
- IT (39)
- Live Events (6)
- Podcast (7)
- Police investigation (10)
- Prosecutions (44)